IQ and heart disease

In Part II of The Bell Curve, which does not mention race (and which is required reading), Murray and Herrnstein show in fascinating detail, based on the U.S. Army’s massive Longitudinal Study of Youth, the correlation between IQ and income, between IQ and law abidingness, between IQ and accident proneness, between IQ and marital stability, and between IQ and many other socioeconomic factors. Since the Longitudinal Study of Youth did not follow its subjects past their thirties, Murray and Herrnstein did not have any data on the relationship between IQ and heart disease and death resulting from heart disease. In an article which reads as though it comes from The Bell Curve, the extremely liberal news agency Reuters fills in that gap.

Low intelligence among top heart health risks
Wed Feb 10, 2010
By Kate Kelland

LONDON (Reuters)—Intelligence comes second only to smoking as a predictor of heart disease, scientists said on Wednesday, suggesting public health campaigns may need to be designed for people with lower IQs if they are to work.

Research by Britain’s Medical Research Council (MRC) found that lower intelligence quotient (IQ) scores were associated with higher rates of heart disease and death, and were more important indicators than any other risk factors except smoking.

Heart disease is the leading killer of men and women in Europe, the United States and most industrialised countries.

According to the World Health Organisation, cardiovascular diseases and diabetes accounted for 32 percent of all deaths around the world in 2005.

It is well known that people with poorer education and lower incomes often face higher risks of ill health and a range of diseases. Studies have pointed to many likely reasons, including limited access to healthcare and other resources, poorer living conditions, chronic stress and higher rates of lifestyle risk factors like smoking.

The MRC study, which analysed data from 1,145 men and women aged around 55 and followed up for 20 years, rated the top five heart disease risk factors as cigarette smoking, IQ, low income, high blood pressure, and low physical activity.

The researchers, led by David Batty of the MRC and Social and Public Health Science Unit in Glasgow, Scotland, said there were “a number of plausible mechanisms” which might explain why lower IQ scores could raise the risk of heart disease—in particular a person’s approach to “healthy behaviour.”

Those who ignored or failed to understand advice about the risks of smoking or benefits of good diet and exercise for heart health would be more likely to be at higher risk, they wrote in a study in the European Journal of Cardiovascular Prevention.

Batty said it was important to recognise the public health implications of the findings—that skills reflected in a person’s IQ may be important for managing heart disease risk.

“From a public health perspective, there is the possibility that IQ can be increased, with some mixed results from trials of early learning and school readiness programmes,” he said.

Ioanna Tzoulaki, a lecturer in epidemiology from Imperial College London, agreed the public health impact was important.

“Public health campaigns should focus on early life factors that have been shown to influence IQ levels and tackle social inequalities,” she said in a comment on the study.

“At the same time, the public health messages for known risk factors such as diet may need to be simplified.”

- end of initial entry -

Mike Berman, who sent the story, writes:

Bob Weissberg sent me the “correct” way to interpret the story:

This has it all wrong. Illness causes low IQ so we must address the root causes—more money for health care, role models and mentors. And rest assured, if “the Man” wanted black people healthy it would happen tomorrow.

Any other questions?

Alex H. writes:

“This life’s hard, man, but it’s harder if you’re stupid!”

—Jackie Brown, the gun runner, in “The Friends of Eddie Coyle,” at 9:05 in this clip

Posted by Lawrence Auster at February 10, 2010 01:58 PM | Send

Email entry

Email this entry to:

Your email address:

Message (optional):